Planning for our March trip with 12 or 14 hungry Iowans. We'll be eating a couple of dinners at home, but after spending the day at the beach, not sure any of us will have enough energy to make dessert from scratch. Anywhere we can purchase one or two whole key lime pies, or key lime cheesecakes, or other good desserts? We are not so lazy that we need delivery---we can pick it up. Thanks much.
I know Baked in the Sun moved to a new location, but if they are still making Key Lime Pies, I HIGHLY recommend them. We got one two trips ago and it was wonderful. Huge and much less expensive than I'd pay for one at a local bakery.
I also want to say you can buy a whole one from Skinny Legs, but I'm not 100% sure.
I called Baked in the Sun and they do have Key Lime Pies available "to go" for $27.00 for a whole pie. Based on Nic in KC's good recommendation, think I may go this route, but if you have any other ideas, keep them coming!
On a totally different dessert note the Chocolate coconut bar AKA coconut crack bar from Deli Grotto could be split and served. Granted not a grand looking dessert for after dinner but they are awesome!
Hi Jim! I would at least call Lime Inn to see if you can purchase whole pies to go...their Key Lime Pie is the best I've had on STJ! Perhaps we'll run into you all in March! Hope you all are well!
usvi-on-line
