We're trying to plan a budget friendly trip, and we know that this result in lots of meals at the villa. However, I'm hoping we will grab a few meals out....which brings me to my question. If you could only eat ONE meal at a restaurant in St. John, where would it be? Alternatively, if you had ONE ni...

We're booked! Had to create this silly ticker to stop the tears of gratitude sliding down my face. THANK YOU all for your advice, it made finding the villa an adventure and I'm grateful to all of you for your help. Put in a request for the Banana Cabana today!

michigan girls, Fair Winds is definitely on my short list. It looks divine.

Knew I could count on you all to keep the good ideas coming! Thank you! Has anyone ever stayed at Banana Cabana?

Thanks everybody! These are some amazing places. Can't wait to show my friends our options! BillVT, you have a gorgeous place!

I'm hoping to bring 3 first-timers to St. John (my fourth trip - official addict). I'm looking for a 2 bedroom villa for 2 couples, and I'm hoping to pay less than $1,800. We have virtually no requirements - I'd have us camping but the other gal is not the camping type. We don't even have dates pick...